How has mathematics gotten so abstract?

https://lcamtuf.substack.com/p/how-has-mathematics-gotten-so-abstract
webpage banner

How has mathematics gotten so abstract?

Today, mathematics is regarded as a supremely abstract science. On forums such as Stack Exchange, trained mathematicians may sneer at newcomers who ask for intuitive explanations of mathematical constructs. Indeed, persistently trying to relate the foundations of math to reality has become the calling card of online cranks. The article delves into the historical evolution of mathematical abstraction, from the intuitive understanding of numbers to the formal axiomatic systems of Peano arithmetic and set theory. It explains how these abstract frameworks, especially in dealing with concepts like infinity and cardinality, lead to counter-intuitive but logically consistent results, such as non-commutative addition with infinite ordinals and the existence of different sizes of infinity demonstrated by Cantor's diagonalization argument. The author explores the philosophical implications of these abstractions and their role in modern mathematics.

Note

the essay's title doesn't feel fully satisfied by the content (unless you are happy with the answer being "sets"). but i guess that is one (of many) paths to how it got there.

but the essay does satisfy in building a nice bridge from non-abstraction (ex: counting) to some pretty quick abstractions (ex: sets) with a little Peano thrown in there to make the steps a bit smaller.

bonus points for the C code as well!

Published

2025

Summary

Today, mathematics is regarded as a supremely abstract science. On forums such as Stack Exchange, trained mathematicians may sneer at newcomers who ask for intuitive explanations of mathematical constructs. Indeed, persistently trying to relate the foundations of math to reality has become the calling card of online cranks. The article delves into the historical evolution of mathematical abstraction, from the intuitive understanding of numbers to the formal axiomatic systems of Peano arithmetic and set theory. It explains how these abstract frameworks, especially in dealing with concepts like infinity and cardinality, lead to counter-intuitive but logically consistent results, such as non-commutative addition with infinite ordinals and the existence of different sizes of infinity demonstrated by Cantor's diagonalization argument. The author explores the philosophical implications of these abstractions and their role in modern mathematics.

Image

Image for How has mathematics gotten so abstract?